I'll be honest and admit my greediness. I started not to share this recipe because, well, I wanted all the glory for myself...but that's just not right. Everyone needs to have the privilege of eating and sharing this fabulous stuff.
I've seen several different versions of this pudding out there, but this one is just so good, I have no reason to stray. And by the way, this recipe is in no way, shape, or form healthy. It has a ton of fat and sugar...and it's freaking awesome! Let's put it this way, the closest recipe to this I've found is Paula Deen's. I suppose this is one of those "in moderation" things ; ) I'll add that I have tried to make it a few times with lower fat/calorie ingredients, and it just doesn't get as fluffy or set as well as when I use the real thing(s).
So, here's what you need:
3 cups Whole Milk (lower fat milk doesn't allow the pudding to set correctly)
1 pkg Vanilla Instant Pudding Mix
1 pkg French Vanilla Instant Pudding Mix
8 oz Cream Cheese
1 can of Eagle Brand Sweetened Condensed Milk
32 oz Cool Whip
1 box Nilla Wafers
4-5 Ripe Bananas
- Whisk together the whole milk with the two pudding mixes in a medium mixing bowl and set in the refrigerator to become firm (2-5 minutes)
- While the pudding sets up, in your largest mixing bowl, use the hand mixer to blend the cream cheese and sweetened condensed milk until smooth
- Again, using the hand mixer, blend the pudding (which should be set by now) and cream cheese/sweetened condensed milk mixture
- At this point, if I feel the pudding/cream cheese/sweetened condensed milk mixture is too warm or viscous (due to hot day, warm kitchen, etc.), I set the whole thing in the refrigerator to set a bit more. This helps the pudding stay fluffy when folding in the Cool Whip
- With a big rubber/silicon spatula, fold the Cool Whip into the pudding mixture. I find it easiest to fold in a third of the Cool Whip in at a time. And yes, it makes a lot.
- Slice up the bananas (I prefer thinly sliced) and get your layer on in whatever serving dish you like (9x13 casserole, trifle bowl, individual cups, etc.)... My layering preference is (from bottom to top) wafers, pudding, bananas, pudding, and so on and so on... I try to go skimpy with the pudding on the bottom layers to make sure that I have enough at the end to have a nice, thick layer on top.
- Then garnish however you like. I do the classic, line the serving dish with wafers and crumbled a few on top, thing.
- Put the whole thing in the refrigerator to chill and set up. I prefer to make it the night before I'm going to serve it because the wafers get a bit softer and the pudding takes on a bit of flavor from the bananas.
Notes:
When I know I'm making this ahead of time, I buy the bananas 2-3 days beforehand so that they'll be ripe and not "grocery store green".
Also, set the Cool Whip and cream cheese out on the counter a couple of hours before making (assuming the Cool Whip is still frozen). The Cool Whip needs to thaw and the cream cheese needs to be almost room temperature. Using the microwave to shortcut this step results in runny pudding. Ask me how I know.
Lastly, read your pudding boxes carefully, as this recipe uses instant and there are both instant and cook & serve boxes sitting next to one another. Again, ask me how I know.
Happy pudding making!